Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann have emerged as the leading candidates to replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United if the club decides to make a managerial change during the November international break.
Pressure has mounted on Carrick following United’s inconsistent start to the season, with the club struggling in the Premier League despite producing entertaining performances in recent matches.
A dramatic 3-2 Champions League victory over Roma and a chaotic 4-4 draw with Aston Villa have provided moments of encouragement, but their domestic form has reportedly left the club’s hierarchy considering its options.
The international break could provide an opportunity for United to reassess the situation, with several high-profile managers already linked with the Old Trafford position.
Here are five potential replacements if the club decides to part ways with Carrick.
1. Eddie Howe
Howe is reportedly one of the strongest candidates to take charge at Old Trafford, with Manchester United technical director Jason Wilcox believed to favour the former Newcastle United manager.
The Englishman established himself as one of the Premier League’s respected coaches after transforming Newcastle into a competitive side capable of qualifying for the Champions League.
His experience in English football, ability to develop players and high-intensity approach could make him an attractive option for United.
His reported availability would also make negotiations considerably easier if the club decides to move quickly.
2. Julian Nagelsmann
Nagelsmann is another leading contender, with United head of recruitment Christopher Vivell reportedly admiring the German tactician.
The former Bayern Munich manager has built a reputation for his tactical flexibility, progressive football and ability to work with young players.
His experience at the highest level, including managing Germany’s national team, makes him an appealing candidate for a club seeking a long-term project.
Nagelsmann could offer United a fresh tactical identity, although the club would need to establish whether he is interested in taking the position.
3. Mauricio Pochettino
Pochettino remains a familiar name whenever the Manchester United managerial position becomes available.
The Argentine has considerable Premier League experience from his spells at Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea, while his coaching philosophy has traditionally centred on aggressive pressing, attacking football and developing young talent.
He previously guided Tottenham to the Champions League final in 2019, strengthening his reputation as a manager capable of building competitive teams.
His experience handling the pressure of English football could work in his favour if United consider making another managerial appointment.
4. Antonio Conte
Conte would represent a more immediate, results-driven option if United wanted an experienced manager capable of delivering silverware.
The Italian has won league titles with Juventus, Chelsea and Inter Milan, establishing himself as one of Europe’s most successful modern coaches.
His demanding approach, tactical discipline and preference for a structured system could help address some of United’s current problems.
However, Conte’s intense management style and reported financial demands could complicate any potential appointment, particularly if the club is looking for a long-term project rather than an immediate turnaround.
5. Kieran McKenna
McKenna could also enter the conversation because of his previous experience at Manchester United, where he worked as an assistant coach before moving into management.
The Northern Irishman built his reputation at Ipswich Town, guiding the club through successive promotions from League One to the Premier League.
His familiarity with United’s environment and experience developing players could appeal to the club’s hierarchy.
However, convincing Ipswich to release their manager during the season could prove difficult, while compensation and his willingness to return to Old Trafford would also need to be considered.
Howe and Nagelsmann lead the race
If Manchester United decide to replace Carrick during the November international break, Howe and Nagelsmann appear to be the leading options based on the reports.
Both managers offer different qualities, with Howe bringing proven Premier League experience and Nagelsmann offering a progressive tactical approach.
Pochettino and Conte would provide alternative routes for the club, while McKenna could appeal if United prioritise continuity and familiarity with its football structure.
For now, Carrick’s immediate future remains the central issue, with the club’s next decision potentially shaping its direction for the remainder of the season.
